My book is Extremely Loud and Incredibly Close, by Jonathan Safran Foer so the filmmaker would probably have quite a few challenges with adapting this book. The first one being, the little boy has a very colorful vocabulary, so only of those parts would have to be changed unless you wanted the movie to be rated R. Also, he would have a challenge making people in the audience like Oskar, his mom, or his grandma, because they are just flat out weird. And, they all act in ways that would make people not really enjoy them for two hours straight.
One scene that is essential to keep would be the scene where Oskar’s dad is telling him the story of the sixth borough of New York. It really shows that Oskar fits with his dad in a way that nothing else really could. Another scene that is essential to keep is the scene where he meets Mr. Black. Mr. Black is cool and crazy, just like any old man and that would really take away from the movie if they didn’t have a crazy old war veteran in there. A third scene that is essential to keep would be the one where Oskar tells his mom that he wishes that she was the one who died in 9/11. This scene shows that they don’t get along, and that their relationship has become really rocky after his dad died.
One thing that you would definitely have to change would be when Oskar thinks about things that he wishes he did. One of those things includes bashing in the head of one of his fellow classmates. This scene would be really graphic, and the audience would not respond well to a violent little child that cried for attention. Another scene that you would have to cut would be where his grandfather is sculpting his grandmother because it is really descriptive and once again, not really good for the audience to see in a book that is supposed to be about a little boy who lost his father.
I haven’t seen the film version of this novel, but I really truly hope that they cut out those specific scenes.