Monday, May 14, 2012

Blog Post 6


Genre Fiction isn’t less worthy than Literary Fiction, it’s almost more worthy because that’s what we read now. Jane Eyre wasn’t popular back when it was written, and it’s Literary Fiction. Genre Fiction is worthy to most people that read now, but in 100 years, the Literary Fiction will probably be considered the more worthy type. I don’t think it’s less worthy, but I understand why we don’t read it, and why we read Literary Fiction. Literary Fiction shows great writing style, and it usually can rope in the time period, people’s perspective, and new writing style that Genre Fiction doesn’t have. There is a difference, but some pieces can be considered both if they are extremely popular, yet still have great controversy and style. Most books that are great you either love or hate. Popular books are able to be great, but they usually aren’t because people read books that are easy and quick, and then those books get popular. I don’t think anybody but the reader gets to decide what good writing is. The reader will like different topics, like everyone on Earth, so only the reader can decide for themselves what is good and bad.

            We shouldn’t just teach that, but we should still incorporate the good old books so students get a variety of the books they read in school. Kids have to be able to moan and say, “Oh man, I have to go get Rebecca. Crap.” They can’t say that about new books, so you have to leave in a few of the old ones so they can complain. I think we should add more genre fiction just so some kids who don’t read outside of school can see that not all writers use extreme vocabulary or weird arrangements of sentences. I don’t think we should swap out Of Mice and Men or Macbeth for Twilight of Hunger Games. We need to see some of those old books, and Twilight has no great writing style or story line that isn’t in old writing. She falls in love with a guy buy can’t be with him. The same thing happened in Jane Eyre. They just don’t need vampires to make it interesting. It should have Jane Eyre, Romeo and Juliet, To Kill a Mockingbird, Harry Potter, My Sister’s Keeper, Odyssey, and Fahrenheit 451. it isn’t relevant, but it shows us what our culture used to be when people still had manners. It is preparing students for the job market they are about to enter because they will know what life used to be, and what it is know, so they hopefully won’t be so ignorant about life. Also, they will know about our history in literature and how far things have changed. We want kids to read so that they can be good at writing for college papers, and so they get to know how to know how to read, and so they understand more when they hear about things in the past or in parts old the world that still have that culture.  

4 comments:

  1. I totally agree that the reader can only decide if a book is good or bad! I also agree that literary fiction is great because it is important enough that we are still reading it today!

    ReplyDelete
  2. I agree that literary fiction has many elements that genre fiction can't provide.

    ReplyDelete
  3. :) I agree that we should add more genre fiction just so some kids who don’t read outside of school can see that not all writers use extreme vocabulary or weird arrangements of sentences.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I agree that adding more genre fiction will help the people that don't read in their free time get into books and start to like them.

    ReplyDelete